Skip navigation

MEDIA ALERT: NEW Watson analysis identifies “serious corruption risk” in Minns Government’s Mount Pleasant Coal Bill by conferring King-like powers on Minister

17 November 2026

New analysis from Geoffrey Watson SC shows that the Mount Pleasant Mine Bill being debated in NSW Parliament this week presents  a “serious corruption risk” to New South Wales.

Watson SC is one of Australia’s foremost corruption experts, including as former Counsel Assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption, where he was lead counsel of the inquiry into the Mount Penny coal exploration licence that found corrupt conduct by former ministers Eddie Obeid and Ian Macdonald.

The Watson Opinion finds that the NSW Government is attempting to give itself “unusually broad” powers, akin to powers in the deeply unpopular Work Choices Act 2005 that were heavily criticised by Labor and criticised by the High Court as “undesirable” and  “ought to be discouraged”.

As identified in the Watson Opinion, the Bill includes a power known as a “Henry VIII clause” because it grants unfettered powers to a Minister to override all other law in the State of NSW for the benefit of a single coal company. By doing so, the Bill gives the Minister power to circumvent the very independent process that was established to ensure integrity in development proposals.

Isabelle Reinecke, Executive Director of the Grata Fund, which funds litigation in the public interest says,

“The Watson Opinion raises serious questions about the NSW Government’s respect for the rule of law and independent judicial system, especially given that the Bill appears to be an attempt to circumvent an ongoing court case between MACH Energy and a New South Wales community group, Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group (DAMSHEG), which will be heard in the Land and Environment Court this week.

“The Bill would give the Resources Minister King-like powers that have no place in our constitutional democratic system and should be raising alarm bells for anyone who does not want NSW to return to the old days of planning corruption. 

“The High Court concluded that planning authorities must consider imposing conditions on mine approvals to reduce the impact of Scope 3 emissions on the public. The Bill proposes ‘technical guidance’ will be devised to assist, but given the NSW Government’s king-maker approach with this Bill, any guidance that does not go through a robust public process, involving expert advice and public consultation, cannot be trusted.

“By rushing through King-making powers to enable a coal company to get around legislation that is designed in the public interest, the NSW Government is saying to the people of New South Wales that "coal companies are in control, not you”.

“At a time when the International Court of Justice has unanimously found that Governments must do everything possible to drastically cut global emissions, it is appalling that the NSW Government is actively working to undermine a community win in the High Court by introducing a special law that will allow a coal company to expand its harmful export business. The NSW Government should withdraw this Bill and reconsider who it is in power to serve — people, not corporate profits.”


Jennifer Robinson, Barrister at Doughty St Chambers, and director of Grata Fund. She was counsel for the Marshall Islands and Vanuatu in the International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion on Climate Change, and is the 2026 recipient of the Sydney Peace Prize, says:

"The International Court of Justice decision on states’ climate obligations sets out Australia’s international obligations in respect of climate change and fossil fuels. As the NSW Net Zero Commission has already warned, expanding coal production is not consistent with meeting these climate commitments and could expose the Commonwealth government to liability under international law.
"The NSW government should withdraw this bill - it undermines the High Court decision, it ignores community concerns and it places the federal government at risk of international liability.”

Background

The Mount Pleasant Mine Bill was introduced by the Minns Government in November, in response to a NSW community win in the High Court in October 2026 (MACH Energy v DAMSHEG). The High Court found that the Independent Planning Commission had not properly applied the law that is designed to protect communities from the harmful impacts of exported coal.

The Bill allows the coal company that lost this case to expand production by an additional 4 million tonnes of coal a year without the economic, social and environmental assessments that would ordinarily apply.

The court case between MACH Energy and DAMSHEG is ongoing, having been remitted by the High Court. As at publication, the next hearing is listed in the Land and Environment Court on 10 December 2026.

Note: Grata Fund has provided charitable funding for limited disbursements to DAMSHEG in their case with MACH Energy. Watson has not been involved in those activities. Suggested language for disclosure: The Grata Fund provided some limited disbursement funding to the litigants in the Mount Pleasant case. Geoffrey Watson was not involved in that decision.

Watson Opinion

Available for interview

  • Geoffrey Watson SC, Geoffrey Watson SC, former Counsel Assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption and director of the Centre for Public Integrity and Grata Fund.

  • Elaine Johnson, Director, Johnson Lawyers and legal representative for DAMSHEG.

Media contact

Sean Kennedy is available to assist on 0447 121 378.

Continue Reading

Read More

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER